On watchIndependent · Reader funded · No paywall
Local · 00:45

Comparing family-monitored alarms with centre-based monitoring

By @thecarecircle

What a family safety alarm does and how it works

When someone lives alone or spends long hours by themselves, a family safety alarm can offer a direct line to help. These devices are worn as a pendant or on the wrist and include a button that, when pressed, alerts someone that the wearer needs assistance. The alert may be a phone call, a text message, or a notification on a mobile app. The person receiving it then decides what to do: call the wearer, contact a neighbour, or arrange for emergency services. The key difference between models lies in who receives that alert and how quickly they can respond.

Two approaches to monitoring

There are broadly two ways an alarm can be monitored. In a centre-based system, the alert goes to a professional call centre that operates around the clock. Staff there answer the call, speak to the wearer through a two-way speaker, and follow a pre-set plan. That plan might involve contacting a family member, sending an ambulance, or calling a neighbour. The centre handles the response from start to finish.

In a family-monitored system, the alert goes directly to people the wearer has nominated. That could be a spouse, an adult child, a sibling, or a neighbour. Those contacts receive the alert on their own phones and are expected to respond. The wearer and their family decide together who is on the contact list and what each person should do. Some systems also allow a backup option, so if no one answers after a set time, the alert can be forwarded to a professional service or to emergency services.

How centre-based monitoring works

Professional monitoring centres are staffed by trained operators who handle calls every day. When an alarm is triggered, the operator sees the wearer's details on screen: name, address, medical conditions, and emergency contacts. They speak to the wearer through the alarm's speaker to find out what is needed. If there is no answer, they assume a serious situation and dispatch help. Operators follow strict protocols and can coordinate with ambulance, fire, or police services.

Comparing family-monitored alarms with centre-based monitoring

The main advantage of a centre-based system is that someone is always available to respond, regardless of the time of day or whether family members are busy, asleep, or out of mobile range. The centre never has a bad connection or a flat battery on a phone. This reliability gives many families peace of mind, especially if the wearer lives far from relatives or if the nominated contacts work shifts or travel frequently.

However, centre-based monitoring usually comes with a monthly fee. That fee covers the cost of staffing the centre, maintaining the technology, and handling calls. For some households, this ongoing cost is a factor worth considering. Additionally, the operator at the centre does not know the wearer personally. They rely on the information stored in their system, which may become outdated if the wearer's health or living situation changes and the records are not updated promptly.

How family-monitored alarms work

Family-monitored systems, sometimes called direct-to-family alarms, send alerts straight to the nominated contacts. The wearer presses the SOS button, and a message or call goes out to the people on their list. Those contacts then respond as they see fit. They might call the wearer, check in via a video call, or go to the home in person. If the situation is urgent, they can call emergency services themselves.

The main benefit of this approach is that the people responding already know the wearer. They know their medical history, their daily routines, and their preferences. This personal knowledge can lead to faster, more appropriate help. For example, a family member might know that the wearer often gets dizzy after taking a certain medication, so they can reassure them while deciding whether to call a doctor. A call centre operator would have to gather that information from scratch.

Family-monitored systems also tend to have no monthly monitoring fees, because the family does the responding. The cost is typically limited to the purchase of the alarm device itself. For some families, this makes the system more affordable over the long term.

When each approach suits best

Choosing between the two depends on the wearer's situation, the availability of family members, and the level of reassurance everyone wants.

Comparing family-monitored alarms with centre-based monitoring

Centre-based monitoring is often a good fit when the wearer lives alone and family members live far away or have unpredictable schedules. It also suits people who want the certainty that a professional will answer every time, even if the wearer cannot speak or is unconscious. For those who have medical conditions that can escalate quickly, such as epilepsy or heart conditions, the reliability of a centre can be valuable.

Family-monitored systems are a strong option when the nominated contacts live close by and are generally able to respond. They work well for people who prefer that their own family handles their care, rather than a stranger. They are also suitable for families who want to avoid ongoing fees and are comfortable managing the response themselves. The wearer may feel more at ease knowing that a familiar voice will answer the call.

Some families find a hybrid approach works best. They use a family-monitored alarm as the primary system, but they also set up a backup that forwards the alert to a professional service if no one in the family responds within a few minutes. This gives the best of both worlds: personal response when possible, and professional backup when needed.

Practical considerations when comparing systems

When looking at family safety alarms, there are a few factors worth checking before deciding.

  • Coverage: Does the alarm work only at home, or does it include GPS tracking for when the wearer is out? Some systems use a mobile app or a cellular connection that works anywhere in the country.
  • Fall detection: Many alarms now include automatic fall detection. This can be a valuable feature for anyone at risk of falls, but it adds to the cost and may trigger false alarms. Check how the system handles false alerts.
  • Battery life: How often does the device need charging or its battery replacing? A device that needs daily charging may be forgotten, while one that lasts months is more convenient.
  • Ease of use: The button should be easy to press, even for someone with limited hand strength or vision. Some alarms have a large button or a pull-cord.
  • Contact list flexibility: Can you add multiple contacts and set different rules for different times of day? Can you change the list easily as circumstances change?

What to look for in a family-monitored system

If you lean toward a family-monitored alarm, check that the system allows for enough contacts and that the notifications are reliable. Some systems send alerts via a mobile app, while others send text messages or phone calls. It is wise to test how quickly the alerts reach the nominated contacts and whether they can be customised. For example, you might want a different set of contacts for daytime and nighttime. A system that supports two-way calling is also useful, because the wearer can talk to the contact through the device itself.

One example of a family-monitored alarm is the system offered by familyr.co.nz. Their device includes SOS alerts, GPS location sharing, fall detection, and two-way calling. It is designed to be used without monthly monitoring fees, with the response handled by the wearer's own family network. This kind of setup suits families who want the wearer to stay independent while staying connected to people who know them well.

What to look for in a centre-based system

If a centre-based system seems right, ask about the centre's accreditation, the operator training, and the average response time. Some centres are certified by national standards bodies, which can give extra confidence. Also check whether the centre can handle the wearer's language or communication needs. A good centre will have protocols for people with hearing or speech difficulties. Finally, confirm the monthly fee and whether there are any additional charges for extra features such as fall detection or GPS tracking.

Comparing family-monitored alarms with centre-based monitoring

Making the decision for your family

The right choice depends on the specific situation of the person who will wear the alarm and the people who will respond. For some, the reliability and 24/7 availability of a centre is essential. For others, the personal touch and lower cost of a family-monitored system is more appealing. There is no single best option for everyone.

If you are unsure, it can help to list the pros and cons for your own family. Consider the health of the wearer, the distance to the nearest relative, the typical daily schedules of the nominated contacts, and the budget for ongoing fees. Some families start with a family-monitored system and add a backup professional service later if they feel the need. Others go straight to a centre-based system for peace of mind.

Whichever path you take, the goal is the same: to give the wearer a way to call for help and to know that someone will respond. A family safety alarm, whether monitored by family or by a centre, can provide that reassurance. It allows older adults, people with disabilities, or anyone who lives alone to go about their day with more confidence. And for the family, it can reduce worry, knowing that help is only a button press away.

For more information on the family-monitored approach, you can visit familyr.co.nz to see how their system works. Their focus is on keeping the response within the family while providing the technology needed for reliable alerts.

Corrections

Spot something wrong? Send it to the desk and it gets fixed in the open.